Difference between revisions of "Options"
From Deliberative Democracy Institiute Wiki
(→Distrebuted Evaluation of options) |
(→Brain Mechanisms) |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
__TOC__ | __TOC__ | ||
==Brain Mechanisms== | ==Brain Mechanisms== | ||
| − | Here et al. (2009)<ref>[http://www.rnl.caltech.edu/publications/pdf/hare2009.pdf Self-control in decision-making involves modulation of the vmPFC valuation system. Todd A Hare, Colin F Camerer, Antonio Rangel(2009) Science 324 (5927) p. 646-8] </ref> found that there is | + | Here et al. (2009)<ref>[http://www.rnl.caltech.edu/publications/pdf/hare2009.pdf Self-control in decision-making involves modulation of the vmPFC valuation system. Todd A Hare, Colin F Camerer, Antonio Rangel(2009) Science 324 (5927) p. 646-8] </ref> found that there is correlation between [[self-control]] and activity in the [[dlPFC]] and [[vmPFC]]. As you practice on self control, there is more blood flow in the dlPFC. It seams that "evidence between the options will be stored in the dlPFC and when a trashold is passed in the vmPFC, the decision will be made. |
| − | It may be that people with more self-control, can | + | It may be that people with more self-control, can withhold verdict until enough evidence are presented. |
The [[ACC]] is thought to be part of the conflict detection system between two deductions. | The [[ACC]] is thought to be part of the conflict detection system between two deductions. | ||
Revision as of 11:48, 2 January 2018
Options are different pathways to reach a solution based on a SON or a MON.
Brain Mechanisms
Here et al. (2009)[1] found that there is correlation between self-control and activity in the dlPFC and vmPFC. As you practice on self control, there is more blood flow in the dlPFC. It seams that "evidence between the options will be stored in the dlPFC and when a trashold is passed in the vmPFC, the decision will be made.
It may be that people with more self-control, can withhold verdict until enough evidence are presented.
The ACC is thought to be part of the conflict detection system between two deductions.
Options in CMC
For every challenge there are may be many options to reach a solution. In CMC several methods were developed to represent options in clear way:
In the developer communities stack overflow is a well familiar method to represent options. In delib.org delib.org mvp1 there is another way. Both ways are adjusted to infinite options. In deliberation infinte options are crucial for mainating the ability of every member to represents his MON.
Most of the people know about one or two or even several options. Voting yes/no is reorientation of one option, which the public can accept or reject. Voting between two or more options is a way to select between small set of options (which are preselected).
Distrebuted Evaluation of options
A distributed evaluation of options can be achieved by the OptPSR algorithm described by Caragiannis et al.[2]
References
- ↑ Self-control in decision-making involves modulation of the vmPFC valuation system. Todd A Hare, Colin F Camerer, Antonio Rangel(2009) Science 324 (5927) p. 646-8
- ↑ Caragiannis, Ioannis, et al. "Optimizing Positional Scoring Rules for Rank Aggregation." AAAI. 2017. (thanks to Nimrod Talmon for the refernce)